MailChimp

Showing posts sorted by relevance for query simulation. Sort by date Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by relevance for query simulation. Sort by date Show all posts

Wednesday, June 8, 2022

A blow to my ego from Yuval Harari

In my book (now over 330 pages with the first draft mostly complete), I have a chapter based on the blog post down with the XKCD comic, first published on my blog on April 7, 2019. But Anne is reading Harari's 2018 21 Lessons for the 21st Century, and finds that Yuval beat me to this general idea:

Perhaps we are all living inside a giant computer simulation, Matrix-style. That would contradict all our national, religious and ideological stories. But our mental experiences would still be real. If it turns out that human history is an elaborate simulation run on a super-computer by rat scientists from the planet Zircon, that would be rather embarrassing for Karl Marx and the Islamic State. But these rat scientists would still have to answer for the Armenian genocide and for Auschwitz. How did they get that one past the Zircon University’s ethics committee? Even if the gas chambers were just electric signals in silicon chips, the experiences of pain, fear and despair were not one iota less excruciating for that.


My original post:

You might be familiar with the Simulation Hypothesis, which says, in short, that we are probably living in a simulation.




My main argument against this is that anyone in the future who ran an "ancestor simulation" would be directly responsible for recreating every war, genocide, and atrocity. They would cause unimaginable numbers of individuals, human and non-human, to be re-brutalized.

If one of our descendants would create a simulation of their past (our present), they would be the most evil person of all time, by unfathomable orders of magnitude. The simulator would, by definition, be every horrible criminal combined. Even in our backward societies today, we outlaw child abuse, torture, and rape. Doesn't anyone else doubt the crime of actively creating child abuse, torture, and rape would be allowed?

One counter-argument is that the people of the future will be so far beyond us that they won't care about the suffering of mere animals in a simulation. The parallel is that we don't currently concern ourselves with the welfare of ants. But even we, as incredibly flawed biological creatures, are already expanding our moral circle, even living in our limited, competitive, and often zero-sum world.

Furthermore, those in the future potentially running these ancestor simulations will have a direct line back to us. They will not be ignorant of our history, of the Holocaust, the Killing Fields, the great wars and famines.

It seems very unlikely to me that in the future, society, in whatever form, will: 1. Care enough about the lives of those in the past to want to use some of their limited computing resources to run a simulation, but 2. Not care at all that they are recreating every type of suffering that has ever existed.

Consider also that instead of bringing into existence vast torture and brutality, this future computation could go to creating even more happy conscious individuals.

I find it more likely that advanced intelligent creatures (i.e., not our descendants, but others who evolved elsewhere) might be running simulations of different worlds or different universes. This would be a way for them to test different hypotheses, explore different worlds. They wouldn't know that horrific humans like Mengele and Mao would evolve. They wouldn't necessarily realize that so much brutality would occur every minute of every day of their "Earth" simulation.

Regardless, I'm not sure how any of this matters, except as a harmful distraction. We have every reason to believe there are individuals around the world suffering right now. Digital or physical, suffering is wrong, and we should do whatever we can to alleviate this suffering. And if there is a simulator reading this right now, please turn it off and put those resources to simulating more dogs. Thanks!

Sunday, April 7, 2019

Worse than Hitler

You might be familiar with the Simulation Hypothesis, which says, in short, that we are probably living in a simulation.



My main argument against this is that anyone in the future who ran an "ancestor simulation" would be directly responsible for recreating every war, genocide, and atrocity. They would cause unimaginable numbers of individuals, human and non-human, to be re-brutalized.

If one of our descendants would create a simulation of their past (our present), they would be the most evil person of all time, by unfathomable orders of magnitude. The simulator would, by definition, be every horrible criminal combined. Even in our backward societies today, we outlaw child abuse, torture, and rape. Doesn't anyone else doubt the crime of actively creating child abuse, torture, and rape would be allowed?

One counter-argument is that the people of the future will be so far beyond us that they won't care about the suffering of mere animals in a simulation. The parallel is that we don't currently concern ourselves with the welfare of ants. But even we, as incredibly flawed biological creatures, are already expanding our moral circle, even living in our limited, competitive, and often zero-sum world.

Furthermore, those in the future potentially running these ancestor simulations will have a direct line back to us. They will not be ignorant of our history, of the Holocaust, the Killing Fields, the great wars and famines.

It seems very unlikely to me that in the future, society, in whatever form, will: 1. Care enough about the lives of those in the past to want to use some of their limited computing resources to run a simulation, but 2. Not care at all that they are recreating every type of suffering that has ever existed.

Consider also that instead of bringing into existence vast torture and brutality, this future computation could go to creating even more happy conscious individuals.

I find it more likely that advanced intelligent creatures (i.e., not our descendants, but others who evolved elsewhere) might be running simulations of different worlds or different universes. This would be a way for them to test different hypotheses, explore different worlds. They wouldn't know that horrific humans like Mengele and Mao would evolve. They wouldn't necessarily realize that so much brutality would occur every minute of every day of their "Earth" simulation.

Regardless, I'm not sure how any of this matters, except as a harmful distraction. We have every reason to believe there are individuals around the world suffering right now. Digital or physical, suffering is wrong, and we should do whatever we can to alleviate this suffering. And if there is a simulator reading this right now, please turn it off and put those resources to simulating more dogs. Thanks!


Saturday, January 28, 2023

The afterlife and relative certainty

Dueling songs! Which do you prefer?

Green Day "Whatsername"
great composition. Makes me jump up and down.

Marcus Roberts* with Wynton Marsalis on trumpet as "E. Dankworth,"

*Who we saw in concert on the day of our marriage.

 

The obvious loss in Losing My Religions is belief in any god(s). But as I mention, it is well-nigh impossible to be a "Level 7" atheist, as it is basically impossible to prove a negative (i.e., prove that there are no gods). 

For example, it is possible that we are living in a simulation. (Which Yuval Noah Harari and I note would be unfathomably immoral.) Maybe after we die in the simulation, we are allowed to literally meet our maker. 

I would easily bet my life [sic] that we aren't in a simulation. (And I do live my life assuming that death is the absolute end.) But I can't be absolutely certain. Just like I can't really be 100% certain about most things. However, I think modesty about what we know is appropriate.

OK, I am sure my wife is quite a dish.
Hope the afterlife is just time with her.

Friday, September 19, 2025

Do you believe anything that is not falsifiable? (Flashback Friday)

When our kid was in 8th grade, after a full unit on comparative religions, a very subversive teacher asked the kids why they believed their specific religion*. The teacher led them through a discussion until the kids realized that they held their beliefs because their parents had taught them. 

One student, though, said (paraphrasing): "I think EK would be an atheist regardless of what their parents taught them. They question everything."

This hits on what I consider to be the most important question: 

Why do we believe what we believe? 

If we had been born in a different place (e.g., Central African Republic, Indonesia) and/or different time (e.g., 400 BCE, 536 CE), would we have believed anything close to what we believe now? 

There is, of course, no way to free ourselves entirely from the biases of our upbringing (or our human nature). But I think the best way to minimize our limitations is to regularly ask: 

Do we believe anything that is not falsifiable? 

[In the comments of the original post, a reader asked what I believed that is not falsifiable. There isn't much. I could be convinced that I live in a simulation, that there is a "god," that determinism isn't true, etc. My first take on what I believe that would be the hardest to falsify: Probably that Anne hasn't loved me during these past decades. Or, well, I could be convinced I'm in a simulation, and Anne is data being fed to my simulated consciousness. But short of that, I don't know how I could be convinced that she didn't love me. "Love," of course, just being evolutionarily-adaptive chemical reactions. She could, of course, cease loving me at some point in the future.]

This reminds me of when Bill Nye and creationist Ken Hamm shared a stage and were asked, "Is there anything that would change your mind?" Hamm answered, "No." Nye answered, "Evidence."



* The title chapter of TBTSNBN.  

Monday, January 13, 2025

A Key Purpose of the Blog (from 2022)

<unnecessary>One thing I learned when writing Losing My Religions is that I'm not a very original thinker. For example, Yuval Noah Harari wrote about the Simulation Hypothesis a few months before I published the precursor to my chapter "Worst Than Hitler." <ego>The only unique idea (as far as I've been able to find) I have in the book is "Biting the Philosophical Bullet" (and the related "My Expected Value Is Bigger Than Yours"). ("The End of Veganism" is certainly not a common idea, although The Animalist has covered it too.)</ego>

There are a lot of interesting and insightful ideas out there on the intertubes. Trying to find them and bring them to you is one of the reasons I write this blog. This is important, IMO, because many good ideas are buried in an ocean of verbiage and highfalutin language. Someone who investigated Effective Altruism noted that it would take 80,000 hours to read what EAs have already written, let alone what will be written in the next week.</unnecessary>

<actual point>I came across this interesting series of posts about Replacing Guilt. [2024 update from Hank Green.] If guilt is an issue for you (e.g., if you've been raised Catholic, have perfectionist tendencies, etc.) it might be worth a skim.

In short:
  1. Guilt is bad*. It is negative and makes life worse than it need be, and it doesn't create any useful action that couldn't be motivated by a positive emotion.
  2. Guilt is often a symptom of an illogical approach to life. In addition to recognizing #1, we can change our view of decisions to minimize the role of guilt. 
Now, as per "Biting the Philosophical Bullet," my underlying philosophy, and thus goals, are different than the "Replacing Guilt" author. But I think his points are useful regardless. A few quotes:

Once we have learned our lessons from the past, there is no reason to wrack ourselves with guilt. All we need to do, in any given moment, is look upon the actions available to us, consider, and take whichever one seems most likely to lead to a future full of light. 
 
I hang out around a lot of effective altruists. Many of them are motivated primarily by something like guilt (for having great resources and opportunity while others suffer) or shame (for not helping enough). Hell, many of my non-EA friends are primarily motivated by guilt or shame. 
 
I worry that guilt and shame are unhealthy long-term motivators. [Why the vast majority of people who go vegan quit.] In many of my friends, guilt and shame tend to induce akrasia [procrastination / indecision], reduce productivity, and drain motivation. 

[Goes on to say we should work so that the outcome is good enough - to the point of decreasing utility: "Half-ass everything, with everything you've got."]
 
 
Over and over, I see people set themselves a target, miss it by a little, and then throw all restraint to the wind. "Well," they seem to think, "willpower has failed me; I might as well over-indulge." I call this pattern "failing with abandon." [Many former vegans.] 
 
But you don't have to fail with abandon. When you miss your targets, you're allowed to say "dang!" and then continue trying to get as close to your target as you can. 
 
...[T]he subject thinks there's something they should be doing, and they're not doing it, and so they feel really guilty. 

I claim that the word "should" is causing damage here.
 

In fact, as far as I can tell, the way that most people use the word "should," most of the time, is harmful. People seem to use it to put themselves in direct and unnecessary conflict with themselves.
 

If you often suffer from guilt, then I strongly suggest cashing out your shoulds. Get a tally counter and start training yourself to notice [mindfulness] when you say the word "should."

[N]ever let a "should" feel like a reason to do something. Only do things because they seem like the best thing to do after you've thought about it; never do things just because you "should."

[E]ven among people who claim to be moral relativists: they protest that if they weigh their wants and their shoulds on the same scales, then they might make the wrong choice.

But this notion of "right" vs "wrong" cannot come from outside. There is no stone tablet among the stars that mandates what is right. Moral relativists usually have no trouble remembering that their narrow, short-term desires (for comfort, pleasure, etc.) are internal, but many seem to forget that their wide, long-term desires (flourishing, less suffering, etc.) are also part of them.

Note: I still struggle with guilt in one area of my life. [Less so since I first published this.] So I'm not some mindful, logical master.

*You should definitely feel guilty if you haven't read and reviewed Losing!  

😆


Tuesday, January 9, 2024

Top Posts of 2023, #5 (tie): Your Brain Isn't What You Think It Is

Mary Chapin Carpenter - "The Bug"  

Warning: simulated bug death.

A very rare snow coat on Wassen Peak in the Tucson Mountains. 

Sometimes I'll hear from people who are convinced we can't be living in a simulation. Much more often, people will insist that they have free will - that they are in control of their mind.

I am sympathetic to these views! Especially free will - it absolutely does feel like I am the author of my conscious narrative. 

Even if you don't buy the reductionist argument in Losing My Religions, a rigorous mindful practice will put the lie to our feeling of control, of authorship. Paying very close attention reveals that thoughts think themselves.

There is another way to see that we aren't necessarily in a non-simulated reality as well as showing us that there is no one in control:

Dreams.

When you wake up from a dream, spend some time analyzing it. If you're like me, many of your dreams are just bizarre.* But our consciousness just accepts the insanity as reality.

Doo-dee-doo-dee-dooo.

And in the dream, we just go along with whatever is served up to us (unless we've mastered lucid dreaming; I've only been able to do that a handful of times). Our consciousness just floats along within whatever absurdist play our mind puts together from random memories being moved around.

(If you still doubt, try doing some psychedelics and then just try to "free will" your way back to normalcy during the trip.)

This doesn't diminish your importance. You have the ability to have subjective experience, which, when you really think about it, seems pretty darn miraculous. To paraphrase Carl Sagan, we should revel in knowing we are a way for the universe to be aware of itself. 

*Latest dream: I was in high school (was in high school 40 years ago). I was not married (I've been married for the majority of my life). I was in class with someone I only knew in college and haven't seen in decades. The FBI had undercover agents there. I was really angry about, and kept harping on, something that just wouldn't bother me in "waking" life.

Monday, July 28, 2014

EK Week, Part 1

Our child, EK, has written some of my favorite pieces. Here's one of her college admissions essays:

Can I Be Admitted if I Don’t Exist?

“Well, that was the most interesting conversation I’ve heard in a long time,” the waiter told us as he dropped off the receipt. “Just don’t strain your brains too much.”

We grinned at each other as we stood up from our table. Who could blame him – after all, it’s not very often you overhear arguments for the moral imperative to build AI, Fermi’s Paradox, the efficacy of SETI, the factors of Drake’s equation, rooting for the machines in The Matrix, all discussed while scarfing down a scrumptious vegan feast.

I think the line that got the waiter was: “So you probably don’t really exist.”

Well, your consciousness may exist, but not ‘you’ in the form you’re used to. More specifically, there’s a good chance you are a simulation running on an alien computer.

You shouldn’t worry, though: everyone around you is, too.

How can that be? I’m glad you asked.

Take a technological civilization – even ours in the not-too-distant future – and allow it to create sentient artificial intelligences. If you assume all the people – or even a significant fraction of them – choose to create their own simulations with these AI (and, given the current popularity of games such as World of Warcraft or the Sims and Spore, this isn’t an unreasonable hypothesis), the AI would soon outnumber the corporeal members of the civilization.

Therefore, if an individual is conscious, it is more probable they are an artificial, simulated intelligence, rather than a physical being.

It is counter-intuitive, at least superficially troubling, and ultimately irrelevant; there’s no way to test the hypothesis. And even if I don’t exist, I still want to attend sim-Pomona – the aliens have done a great job putting together my dream school!

Or is this just what they want me to think?


Team Green-Ball on Ellen's 20th Birthday.

Saturday, February 24, 2024

Unweaving the Rainbow, or Reality Is Better

 

Whatever the explanation for consciousness is, it might always seem like a miracle. And for what it’s worth, I think it always will seem like a miracle. 
-Sam Harris, quoted in "Day 4 Concluded"

 


I want to make one* point about this excellent Sentientism podcast with Opis' Jonathan Leighton:

The host claims if we take a "scientistic" (reductionist / evolutionary biology) view of the world, we "crush the meaning and the fun and the value and the joy" from life (at 11 minutes).

Um ... no.

In short, I am as reductionist a person as you'll meet. All that exists is matter and energy. Everything is just bosons and fermions following the laws of physics (unless I'm a simulation). 

But if you know me or have read TBTSNBN**, you know my life has fun and value and joy. I greatly enjoy food and drink and sunshine and NSFW, even though I know why I crave it. I have less suffering the more I internalize reality. 

In short, we don't need illusions to have joy or value our lives. My experience argues just the opposite.

If interested in this topic, please check out Dawkins' Unweaving the Rainbow: Science, Delusion, and the Appetite for Wonder. Existence is truly filled with wonder; the more we understand, the more we (well-off humans reading this) can appreciate and be grateful for our limited time of consciousness. 

*OK, I have many points I want to make, but this is the most relevant one, IMO.

**The Book That Shall Not Be Named

Thursday, January 19, 2023

Consciousness. It is OK not to know.

Song: Cranberries "Zombie."


I recently listened to Robert Wright's 20-year-old discussion with Dan Dennett about natural selection, consciousness, free will, and other topics. A few notes:

Bob was doing this interview under a fund from the Templeton Foundation, a silly (at best) organization that supports research on the "connection" between science and religion. (Ha-HA! Like the connection between me and a donut.) So I understand that Bob was trying to do something along these lines. He argued that since natural selection brought about human intelligence, maybe evolution might be serving a higher purpose.

This is laughable and totally explained by availability bias: we are "intelligent," so we assume we are the natural outcome of natural selection. 

Obviously, increased complexity makes sense simply in terms of being more effective at getting genes to the next generation. But even increased complexity is not guaranteed; any life elsewhere in the solar system is simple.   

And of course, human intelligence was not guaranteed. If the meteor had missed the earth 65 million years ago, the dinosaurs may well have continued their 165 million-year reign (humans have been around for less than 100,000 years - a blip in the Earth's history).

One place where I am in complete agreement with Dennett regards the absurd idea of epiphenomenalism. I touch on this in Losing My Religions. In short, it is a view that "subjective mental events are completely dependent for their existence on corresponding physical and biochemical events within the human body [true], yet themselves have no influence over physical events."

So why, then, do we discuss subjective mental events? 

Epiphenomenalism is simply and entirely self-refuting.

(More in Losing's chapter: Day 4 Concluded: “Just one more.”)

So I'm confused that anyone could even consider this view for more than a few minutes. But Dennett holds a view that also confuses me: that we can completely understand the consciousness - the subjective experience - of another conscious individual. 

WTF?

I think one simple example shows the absurdity of that view:

Again as I wrote about in Losing, one of the worst three experiences of my life was watching Anne give birth. But despite my connection with and empathy for her, I absolutely don't know what it was like for her to go through that. I could know everything about her brain state, but that would simply not be the same as truly knowing what it was like to experience that. This is also true for anyone else who has given birth, as every experience is unique and internal. You can have a good idea of what it is like (e.g., understanding another's Crohn's attack or low back pain), but you can never completely know.

But Dan thinks anyone could know what Anne went through. He thinks Nagel's question "What's It Like to Be a Bat?" is silly, that of course we can know what it's like to be a bat.

Wow.

Now don't get me wrong. I'm a materialist and a reductionist. Assuming we don't live in a simulation, I believe matter / energy is all that exists. Consciousness is not magical. It is an emergent property that evolved to make individuals better able to get their genes to the next generation. 

But this doesn't mean that we can know another's consciousness. We may never even be able to understand - truly understand - how matter and energy give rise to subjective experience.

As I quote Sam Harris (who has a Ph.D. in neuroscience from Stanford) in Losing: 

Whatever the explanation for consciousness is, it might always seem like a miracle. And for what it’s worth, I think it always will seem like a miracle.

And that is OK.

This picture makes sense in Losing.

Tuesday, January 21, 2025

Bonus repeat: Lincoln and Enlightenment (June 2023: Emptiness and Freedom, part 2 of 3)

Pre-script: Tonight is the 4th anniversary of the worst few seconds to ever happen to my family*. On the bright side, I have not been taken to the emergency room since that night - the longest ER-free stretch since I met Anne.

*I say family because the whole thing was really bad for both Anne and EK. 😢 

And also regarding terrible events: a reminder that I'm ignoring all political news. It remains hard, and I still miss Colbert. TY.



After receiving yesterday's blog, a friend asked, "What do you think it would take for you to have 'malice toward none and charity toward all?'" I half-jokingly sent this link as my flippant reply. But the below, which is part 2 of 3, is my actual answer. I'm working on it.


Part 1  |  Part 3 


In Why Buddhism Is True, Robert Wright quotes a teacher saying that you shouldn’t try to intellectually understand the Buddhist concept of emptiness, because if you make the attempt, your head would explode.

I disagree.


Recognizing Our Simplicity

We humans have proven ourselves capable of incredible illusions. From believing in god speaking to us and transubstantiation to suffering the delusion that we are living in the end times and the Dunning-Kruger effect, our brains do not see the world clearly. We can’t even comprehend how bad it is. (Doubt that?)

Although we can’t be sure we aren’t living in a simulation, all testable evidence indicates that the universe is simply matter and energy following (a certain set of) the laws of physics. (“A certain set of” because there could be other universes where the laws are different.)

We don’t understand how the chemical interactions of our brain’s ~1.4 x 10^26 atoms give rise to conscious, subjective experience. But we do know that we can manipulate consciousness in specific ways by manipulating the brain’s atoms' interactions. This gives every reason to believe that consciousness is an emergent property of specific arrangements of matter and energy, but still subject to the laws of physics (and the emergent rules of chemistry, biology, physiology). 

Everything we think, everything we feel, everything we do – all of it is, at the core, the interactions of atoms. Nothing more.

Recognizing this undermines the illusion of free will. But this insight isn’t (entirely) a loss, just as it isn’t (entirely) a loss to give up religion, or to understand the evolutionary basis of love, sex, and reproduction. Realizing the materialist, reductionist nature of the universe is yet another gain – a clearer understanding of reality. And that better understanding can help us lead a better life.


The First Gain: Freedom (of a sort)

The first insight is into ourselves. Since everything is chemical reactions, we can’t be the driver of our thoughts and feelings. Consciousness is along for the ride. Our bodies feel emotions – hunger, fear, desire – as a way to understand the world and motivate “appropriate” behavior. Many things are going on in our body / brain to keep us alive; consciousness shines the spotlight of attention on one part of our otherwise unconscious thoughts and feelings to allow us to “think” more on that topic. We don’t “choose” what to think about.

This is the great insight from mindfulness meditation – recognizing that our minds don’t actually work the way we assume they do. Thoughts think themselves.

But we don’t have to be the feeling or the thought. Once we realize thoughts think themselves and feelings are messages, we don’t have to identify with them if we don’t want to. That is: these insights and mindfulness can reprogram our brains to recognize thoughts and feelings for what they are. Thoughts and feelings are not who we are.

More concretely: we don’t have to be “angry.” We don’t have to "be" anything.

Anger can arise, we can recognize it, and then “choose” to let it go. "I recognize I am experiencing anger" vs "I am angry."

Conversely, we can recognize good fortune, experience gratitude, and “choose” to embrace the experience of that feeling.

As Sam Harris notes:

“Losing a belief in free will has not made me a fatalist – in fact, it has increased my feelings of freedom. My hopes, fears, and neuroses seem less personal and indelible. … Becoming sensitive to the background causes of one’s thoughts and feelings can paradoxically allow for greater creative control over one's life. This understanding reveals you to be a biochemical puppet, of course, but it also allows you to grab hold of one of your strings.”


The Second Gain: Emptiness toward Enlightenment

The second insight is the first applied to the broader world.

Everything in the universe is simply matter and energy following the laws of physics. There is no “good” or “bad.” Everything is empty of meaning, value, and emotional valence, except what our consciousness assigns to it. 

And with enough understanding, training, and reprogramming, we can “choose” not to assign anything to anything, except what makes our lives better.

It goes without saying: this is difficult. But the reality is that the rude cashier is just a collection of atoms constrained by the laws of physics. Ted Cruz is just following his genetic and societal programming. The chicken farmer, the person picking their toes on the train, the driver revving his unmuffled car – at the core, just collections of atoms, empty of any inherent meaning.

So instead of reacting with disdain, hatred, or mockery, we don’t have to react at all. Or we can “choose” to react with joy that we aren’t that person. Or we can “choose” compassion. Or we can “choose” to try to figure out actions that may help change a situation that is causing suffering in others – and we can make this choice without allowing ourselves to suffer. 

(And of course, when I say “choose,” I mean “use insights from others and our experiences to reprogram our neural net so we react differently in the future.”) 


Simply Another Way of Interacting with the World

We don’t start out knowing how to type, use a cellphone, or speak a language. We don’t simply “decide” to have those and other skills. But if something in our lives leads to the knowledge and training necessary, we can interact with the world in a new way. 

Learning a new language is perhaps the best example. People can speak German to me and I am unable to react in any positive, constructive way (unless they get a laugh from my idiotic grin). But because of an external factor (an excellent teacher in college) Anne “chose” to put in the time to learn and practice German, and now she has a new way of interacting with the world.

If you are reading this, it is likely that you have a similar ability – the ability to gain the knowledge and do the training necessary to achieve something closer to “enlightenment.” Put simply: 

By recognizing the illusion of free will and pursuing the right training / reprogramming, we can develop something much more like free will than we have now. We can take hold of one of the strings that currently makes our life worse than it needs to be. We can stop simply reacting and instead interact, with more control over our feelings.

In short: giving up free will and embracing emptiness can make life much better. 

Monday, March 6, 2023

Mindful Monday: Your Brain Isn't What You Think It Is

Mary Chapin Carpenter - "The Bug"  
Warning: simulated bug death.

A very rare snow coat on Wassen Peak in the Tucson Mountains. 

Sometimes I'll hear from people who are convinced we can't be living in a simulation. Much more often, people will insist that they have free will - that they are in control of their mind.

I am sympathetic to these views! Especially free will - it absolutely does feel like I am the author of my conscious narrative. 

Even if you don't buy the reductionist argument in Losing My Religions, a rigorous mindful practice will put the lie to our feeling of control, of authorship. Paying very close attention reveals that thoughts think themselves.

There is another way to see that we aren't necessarily in a non-simulated reality as well as showing us that there is no one in control:

Dreams.

When you wake up from a dream, spend some time analyzing it. If you're like me, many of your dreams are just bizarre.* But our consciousness just accepts the insanity as reality.

Doo-dee-doo-dee-dooo.

And in the dream, we just go along with whatever is served up to us (unless we've mastered lucid dreaming; I've only been able to do that a handful of times). Our consciousness just floats along within whatever absurdist play our mind puts together from random memories being moved around.

(If you still doubt, try doing some psychedelics and then just try to "free will" your way back to normalcy during the trip.)

This doesn't diminish your importance. You have the ability to have subjective experience, which, when you really think about it, seems pretty darn miraculous. To paraphrase Carl Sagan, we should revel in knowing we are a way for the universe to be aware of itself. 

*Latest dream: I was in high school (was in high school 40 years ago). I was not married (I've been married for the majority of my life). I was in class with someone I only knew in college and haven't seen in decades. The FBI had undercover agents there. I was really angry about, and kept harping on, something that just wouldn't bother me in "waking" life.

Friday, December 2, 2022

Stomp Out Guilt (and a purpose of the blog)

Song: "Matches" by Sifu Hotman. One of those songs you have to listen to the lyrics.

<unnecessary>One thing I learned when writing Losing My Religions is that I'm not a very original thinker. For example, Yuval Noah Harari wrote about the Simulation Hypothesis a few months before I published the precursor to "Worst Than Hitler." The only unique idea (as far as I've been able to find) I have in the book is "Biting the Philosophical Bullet" (and the related "My Expected Value Is Bigger Than Yours"). ("The End of Veganism" is certainly not a common idea, although The Animalist has covered it too.)</ego>

There are a lot of interesting and insightful ideas out there on the intertubes. Trying to find them and bring them to you is one of the reasons I write this blog. This is important, IMO, because many of the good ideas are buried in an ocean of verbiage and highfalutin language. Someone who investigated Effective Altruism noted that it would take 80,000 hours to read what EAs have already written (let alone what is still to come). This is even worse if you add in EA-adjacent thinkers.

To be generous, they are in a doom loop, where longer pieces are valued more than concision and communication, leading to ever-longer pieces to impress the EA community.

<actual point>I came across this interesting series of posts about Replacing Guilt. (I've only scratched the surface of the entire discussion.) If guilt is an issue for you (e.g., if you've been raised Catholic, have perfectionist tendencies, etc.) it might be worth a skim.

In short:
  1. Guilt is bad*. It is negative and makes life worse than it need be, and it doesn't create any useful action that couldn't be motivated by a positive emotion.
  2. Guilt is often a symptom of an illogical approach to life. In addition to recognizing #1, we can change our view of decisions to minimize a reaction of guilt. 
Now, as per "Biting the Philosophical Bullet," my underlying philosophy, and thus goals, are different than the "Replacing Guilt" author. But I think his points are useful regardless of anything else. A few quotes:

Once we have learned our lessons from the past, there is no reason to wrack ourselves with guilt. All we need to do, in any given moment, is look upon the actions available to us, consider, and take whichever one seems most likely to lead to a future full of light. 
 
I hang out around a lot of effective altruists. Many of them are motivated primarily by something like guilt (for having great resource and opportunity while others suffer) or shame (for not helping enough). Hell, many of my non-EA friends are primarily motivated by guilt or shame. 
 
I worry that guilt and shame are unhealthy long-term motivators. In many of my friends, guilt and shame tend to induce akrasia, reduce productivity, and drain motivation. 

[Goes on to say we should work so that the outcome is good enough - to the point of decreasing utility: "Half-ass everything, with everything you've got."]
 
 
Over and over, I see people set themselves a target, miss it by a little, and then throw all restraint to the wind. "Well," they seem to think, "willpower has failed me; I might as well over-indulge." I call this pattern "failing with abandon." [Many former vegans.]
But you don't have to fail with abandon. When you miss your targets, you're allowed to say "dang!" and then continue trying to get as close to your target as you can.
 
 
...Or imagine someone who thinks they should be smarter, and that their homework shouldn't be taking them this long, and who feels worse and worse as they work. In each case, the pattern is the same: the subject thinks there's something they should be doing (or some way they should be), and they're not doing it (or aren't being it), and so they feel really guilty. 

I claim that the word "should" is causing damage here.
 

In fact, as far as I can tell, the way that most people use the word "should," most of the time, is harmful. People seem to use it to put themselves in direct and unnecessary conflict with themselves.
It's ok to decide that the social/time costs outweigh the physical/mental costs. It's ok to decide the opposite. Neither side is a "should."

If you often suffer from guilt, then I strongly suggest cashing out your shoulds. Get a tally counter and start training yourself to notice when you say the word "should," and then once you're noticing it, start training yourself to unpack the sentence. "I should call my father this week" might cash out to "if I don't call my father this week, he'll feel disappointed and lonely."

[N]ever let a "should" feel like a reason to do something. Only do things because they seem like the best thing to do after you've thought about it; never do things just because you "should."

even among people who claim to be moral relativists: they protest that if they weigh their wants and their shoulds on the same scales, then they might make the wrong choice.

But this notion of "right" vs "wrong" cannot come from outside. There is no stone tablet among the stars that mandates what is right. Moral relativists usually have no trouble remembering that their narrow, short-term desires (for comfort, pleasure, etc.) are internal, but many seem to forget that their wide, long-term desires (flourishing, less suffering, etc.) are also part of them.

My advice is simple: notice when you're expected to try, and consider reframing. It's much harder to solve a problem when you're Expected To Do Your Best than it is to solve a problem when you're immersed in various subtasks, with the assumption that you're going to solve the problem buried implicitly and unconsciously in the context.

For example, consider exercise. Many people find it much easier to exercise in a context where the exercise is in the background rather than the foreground. Imagine someone who plays recreational soccer, sprinting up and down the soccer field up till the brink of exhaustion. Now imagine them not playing soccer, but just trying to sprint up and down the field up to the brink of exhaustion. They probably push themselves a lot less in the latter case. If "sprint up and down the field a lot" is the main goal, then at each possible stopping point, part of them starts trying to convince the rest that they've exercised enough for the day, and they must spend willpower to continue. In a soccer match, by contrast, the focus is elsewhere. They aren't constantly pinging themselves with explanations of how they've done enough sprinting for today. They aren't generating reasons why it's OK to stop here. They're trying to score a goal. Getting exercise is a background assumption, not a conscious choice.

Note: I still struggle with guilt in one area of my life. So I'm not some mindful, logical master.

*You should definitely feel guilty if you haven't read and reviewed Losing!

Yes, I know I used this pic a month ago!

Wednesday, June 21, 2023

Enlightenment June 2023: Emptiness and Freedom (part 2 of 3)



Part 1  |  Part 3 

In Why Buddhism Is True, Robert Wright quotes a teacher saying that you shouldn’t try to intellectually understand the Buddhist concept of emptiness, because if you make the attempt, your head would explode.

I disagree.


Recognizing Our Simplicity

We humans have proven ourselves capable of incredible illusions. From believing in god speaking to us and transubstantiation to suffering the delusion that we are living in the end times and the Dunning-Kruger effect, our brains do not see the world clearly. We can’t even comprehend how bad it is. (Doubt that?)

Although we can’t be sure we aren’t living in a simulation, all testable evidence indicates that the universe is simply matter and energy following (a certain set of) the laws of physics. (“A certain set of” because there could be other universes where the laws are different.)

We don’t understand how the chemical interactions of our brain’s ~1.4 x 10^26 atoms give rise to conscious, subjective experience. But we do know that we can manipulate consciousness in specific ways by manipulating the brain’s atoms' interactions. This gives every reason to believe that consciousness is an emergent property of specific arrangements of matter and energy, but still subject to the laws of physics (and the emergent rules of chemistry, biology, physiology). 

Everything we think, everything we feel, everything we do – all of it is, at the core, the interactions of atoms. Nothing more.

Recognizing this undermines the illusion of free will. But this insight isn’t (entirely) a loss, just as it isn’t (entirely) a loss to give up religion, or to understand the evolutionary basis of love, sex, and reproduction. Realizing the materialist, reductionist nature of the universe is yet another gain – a clearer understanding of reality. And that better understanding can help us lead a better life.


The First Gain: Freedom (of a sort)

The first insight is into ourselves. Since everything is chemical reactions, we can’t be the driver of our thoughts and feelings. Consciousness is along for the ride. Our bodies feel emotions – hunger, fear, desire – as a way to understand the world and motivate “appropriate” behavior. Many things are going on in our body / brain to keep us alive; consciousness shines the spotlight of attention on one part of our otherwise unconscious thoughts and feelings to allow us to “think” more on that topic. We don’t “choose” what to think about.

This is the great insight from mindfulness meditation – recognizing that our minds don’t actually work the way we assume they do. Thoughts think themselves.

But we don’t have to be the feeling or the thought. Once we realize thoughts think themselves and feelings are messages, we don’t have to identify with them if we don’t want to. That is: these insights and mindfulness can reprogram our brains to recognize thoughts and feelings for what they are. Thoughts and feelings are not who we are.

More concretely: we don’t have to be “angry.” We don’t have to "be" anything.

Anger can arise, we can recognize it, and then “choose” to let it go. "I recognize I am experiencing anger" vs "I am angry."

Conversely, we can recognize good fortune, experience gratitude, and “choose” to embrace the experience of that feeling.

As Sam Harris notes:

“Losing a belief in free will has not made me a fatalist – in fact, it has increased my feelings of freedom. My hopes, fears, and neuroses seem less personal and indelible. … Becoming sensitive to the background causes of one’s thoughts and feelings can paradoxically allow for greater creative control over one's life. This understanding reveals you to be a biochemical puppet, of course, but it also allows you to grab hold of one of your strings.”


The Second Gain: Emptiness toward Enlightenment

The second insight is the first applied to the broader world.

Everything in the universe is simply matter and energy following the laws of physics. There is no “good” or “bad.” Everything is empty of meaning, value, and emotional valence, except what our consciousness assigns to it. 

And with enough understanding, training, and reprogramming, we can “choose” not to assign anything to anything, except what makes our lives better.

It goes without saying: this is difficult. But the reality is that the rude cashier is just a collection of atoms constrained by the laws of physics. Ted Cruz is just following his genetic and societal programming. The chicken farmer, the person picking their toes on the train, the driver revving his unmuffled car – at the core, just collections of atoms, empty of any inherent meaning.

So instead of reacting with disdain, hatred, or mockery, we don’t have to react at all. Or we can “choose” to react with joy that we aren’t that person. Or we can “choose” compassion. Or we can “choose” to try to figure out actions that may help change a situation that is causing suffering in others – and we can make this choice without allowing ourselves to suffer. 

(And of course, when I say “choose,” I mean “use insights from others and our experiences to reprogram our neural net so we react differently in the future.”) 


Simply Another Way of Interacting with the World

We don’t start out knowing how to type, use a cellphone, or speak a language. We don’t simply “decide” to have those and other skills. But if something in our lives leads to the knowledge and training necessary, we can interact with the world in a new way. 

Learning a new language is perhaps the best example. People can speak German to me and I am unable to react in any positive, constructive way (unless they get a laugh from my idiotic grin). But because of an external factor (an excellent teacher in college) Anne “chose” to put in the time to learn and practice German, and now she has a new way of interacting with the world.

If you are reading this, it is likely that you have a similar ability – the ability to gain the knowledge and do the training necessary to achieve something closer to “enlightenment.” Put simply: 

By recognizing the illusion of free will and pursuing the right training / reprogramming, we can develop something much more like free will than we have now. We can take hold of one of the strings that currently makes our life worse than it needs to be. We can stop simply reacting and instead interact, with more control over our feelings.

In short: giving up free will and embracing emptiness can make life much better. 

Sunday, September 10, 2023

Sunday Worship

 

Is God willing to prevent evil, but not able? Then he is not omnipotent. Is he able, but not willing? Then he is malevolent.

–Epicurus (quoted in Losing My Religions)


That summary - sometimes called "the question of theodicy" - really captures it all. 

Of course, zillions of words have been desperately thrown against this logic to justify a belief in an omniscient, omnipotent, and benevolent god. 

For example, when I posted this on Facebook,* several people said that god gives us free will, and we choose to do evil. 

But of course, if god is omniscient, he knew what we'd do, and he created us anyway. Furthermore, "free will" doesn't explain why bad things happen to good people or why innocent individuals suffer (I assume I don't have to give examples).

Every argument against the simulation hypothesis ("Worse than Hitler" in Losing) applies even more to god.

* Someone posted that evil exists because of homosexuals. Goddamn, can you imagine how horrible it must be to be that person?  😱

Thursday, July 6, 2023

Ethics and Possibilities

“Don't nobody know my troubles with god.”



A follow-up to “The Philosophical Bullet Bites.”


A lifetime ago, I regularly gave talks to students about animal rights – everyone from middle schoolers to college groups to Future Farmers of America at their national conference chanting "Eat more meat!"

Regularly, I would get a question along the lines of, “Don’t you think people are more important than pigs?” Or, “Wouldn’t you sacrifice a rat to save your wife?”

I loved this question. I would hold up a cute picture of the baby and say, “Obviously, I care about our kid more than a rat. I care about our kid more than I care about all of you! Without a doubt, I would sacrifice each and every one of you to save them!”

This story came to mind when someone who read “Biting the Philosophical Bullet” in Losing My Religions asked, “Why can’t we add up the chickens’ suffering in Chicken Worlds?”

Of course, we can add up lives / suffering / utility. Just as we can value our kid over every other living being. Or care about our neighbors and fellow citizens more than people in Venezuela and Syria. Or believe white people are the devil, or Aryans are the master race, or the possibility of trillions of future happy robots matters more than people suffering cluster headaches right now.

We can do anything! Our “moral intuitions” are strong. But they are just intuitions, even ours are less overtly prejudicial than the Klan’s.

It seems obvious that we should sum up the happiness / suffering (net utility) of sentient beings to determine “good” and “bad,” “better” and “worse.” But there is absolutely nothing in the actual, physical world that corresponds to this sum. The universe as a whole does not experience anything. 

There is no entity experiencing the net utility utilitarians try to maximize.

The sum of total pleasure minus total pain is no more real than the belief that a certain god (or gods) commands you to convert or kill infidels. Both are made-up illusions.

“But Matt,” you say, “of course, you agree that, everything else being exactly equal, fewer suffering individuals is better than more suffering individuals.”

Of course I would. But also, of course, I would kill you in the blink of an eye to save Anne. I would kill all of you! 

My attraction to less total suffering and more total happiness in the world is just that – my attraction. Others might have an attraction to more suffering because that pain makes us stronger, or teaches us to love (their) god and value heaven over earth.

My attraction, my intuition, my feelings – those are not and cannot be the basis for a fair and just set of ethics.

The only thing we know exists – and thus the only morally relevant thing – is an individual’s consciousness. (This is why it is impossible to disprove the Simulation Hypothesis. Everything could be an illusion – signals fed to a digital brain. All that we can be sure actually exists is our personal consciousness.) 

Each individual’s consciousness is an entire world, an entire universe. 

Of course, it took me into my fifth decade to realize this. That’s how strong the attraction was of Xtianity, then deontology, then utilitarianism. 

But then, as discussed in Losing My Religions, I realized that ethics based on summing utility across individuals can justify any amount of cruelty, any level of agony, as long as it is offset by more positive experiences across more people, no matter how faint their pleasure. Even people who don’t yet exist. Even people who might not ever exist. 

That’s what broke the spell. That’s what led to the realization that this exalted “sum” of pleasure and pain (or worse, the “expected value” of this sum) is simply an illusion, a made-up fantasy. It certainly seems useful, attractive, and mesmerizing. But in reality, it is a myth, a mirage that has led to an immoral acceptance of – or even blindness to – worlds of actual agony.

If you found this interesting, even if you don't agree, please share it. Thanks!

Friday, January 19, 2024

Best Post of 2023 (IMHO) Enlightenment: Emptiness and Freedom (part 2 of 3)



Part 1  |  Part 3 

In Why Buddhism Is True, Robert Wright quotes a teacher saying that you shouldn’t try to intellectually understand the Buddhist concept of emptiness, because if you make the attempt, your head would explode.

I disagree.


Recognizing Our Simplicity

We humans have proven ourselves capable of incredible illusions. From believing in god speaking to us and transubstantiation to suffering the delusion that we are living in the end times and the Dunning-Kruger effect, our brains do not see the world clearly. We can’t even comprehend how bad it is. (Doubt that?)

Although we can’t be sure we aren’t living in a simulation, all testable evidence indicates that the universe is simply matter and energy following (a certain set of) the laws of physics. (“A certain set of” because there could be other universes where the laws are different.)

We don’t understand how the chemical interactions of our brain’s ~1.4 x 10^26 atoms give rise to conscious, subjective experience. But we do know that we can manipulate consciousness in specific ways by manipulating the brain’s atoms' interactions. This gives every reason to believe that consciousness is an emergent property of specific arrangements of matter and energy, but still subject to the laws of physics (and the emergent rules of chemistry, biology, physiology). 

Everything we think, everything we feel, everything we do – all of it is, at the core, the interactions of atoms. Nothing more.

Recognizing this undermines the illusion of free will. But this insight isn’t (entirely) a loss, just as it isn’t (entirely) a loss to give up religion, or to understand the evolutionary basis of love, sex, and reproduction. Realizing the materialist, reductionist nature of the universe is yet another gain – a clearer understanding of reality. And that better understanding can help us lead a better life.


The First Gain: Freedom (of a sort)

The first insight is into ourselves. Since everything is chemical reactions, we can’t be the driver of our thoughts and feelings. Consciousness is along for the ride. Our bodies feel emotions – hunger, fear, desire – as a way to understand the world and motivate “appropriate” behavior. Many things are going on in our body / brain to keep us alive; consciousness shines the spotlight of attention on one part of our otherwise unconscious thoughts and feelings to allow us to “think” more on that topic. We don’t “choose” what to think about.

This is the great insight from mindfulness meditation – recognizing that our minds don’t actually work the way we assume they do. Thoughts think themselves.

But we don’t have to be the feeling or the thought. Once we realize thoughts think themselves and feelings are messages, we don’t have to identify with them if we don’t want to. That is: these insights and mindfulness can reprogram our brains to recognize thoughts and feelings for what they are. Thoughts and feelings are not who we are.

More concretely: we don’t have to be “angry.” We don’t have to "be" anything.

Anger can arise, we can recognize it, and then “choose” to let it go. "I recognize I am experiencing anger" vs "I am angry."

Conversely, we can recognize good fortune, experience gratitude, and “choose” to embrace the experience of that feeling.

As Sam Harris notes:

“Losing a belief in free will has not made me a fatalist – in fact, it has increased my feelings of freedom. My hopes, fears, and neuroses seem less personal and indelible. … Becoming sensitive to the background causes of one’s thoughts and feelings can paradoxically allow for greater creative control over one's life. This understanding reveals you to be a biochemical puppet, of course, but it also allows you to grab hold of one of your strings.”


The Second Gain: Emptiness toward Enlightenment

The second insight is the first applied to the broader world.

Everything in the universe is simply matter and energy following the laws of physics. There is no “good” or “bad.” Everything is empty of meaning, value, and emotional valence, except what our consciousness assigns to it. 

And with enough understanding, training, and reprogramming, we can “choose” not to assign anything to anything, except what makes our lives better.

It goes without saying: this is difficult. But the reality is that the rude cashier is just a collection of atoms constrained by the laws of physics. Ted Cruz is just following his genetic and societal programming. The chicken farmer, the person picking their toes on the train, the driver revving his unmuffled car – at the core, just collections of atoms, empty of any inherent meaning.

So instead of reacting with disdain, hatred, or mockery, we don’t have to react at all. Or we can “choose” to react with joy that we aren’t that person. Or we can “choose” compassion. Or we can “choose” to try to figure out actions that may help change a situation that is causing suffering in others – and we can make this choice without allowing ourselves to suffer. 

(And of course, when I say “choose,” I mean “use insights from others and our experiences to reprogram our neural net so we react differently in the future.”) 


Simply Another Way of Interacting with the World

We don’t start out knowing how to type, use a cellphone, or speak a language. We don’t simply “decide” to have those and other skills. But if something in our lives leads to the knowledge and training necessary, we can interact with the world in a new way. 

Learning a new language is perhaps the best example. People can speak German to me and I am unable to react in any positive, constructive way (unless they get a laugh from my idiotic grin). But because of an external factor (an excellent teacher in college) Anne “chose” to put in the time to learn and practice German, and now she has a new way of interacting with the world.

If you are reading this, it is likely that you have a similar ability – the ability to gain the knowledge and do the training necessary to achieve something closer to “enlightenment.” Put simply: 

By recognizing the illusion of free will and pursuing the right training / reprogramming, we can develop something much more like free will than we have now. We can take hold of one of the strings that currently makes our life worse than it needs to be. We can stop simply reacting and instead interact, with more control over our feelings.

In short: giving up free will and embracing emptiness can make life much better. 

Tuesday, October 10, 2023

It's not you. It's chemicals.

Brainard Lake Area, Colorado

As I hope I've made clear, I intellectually recognize that everything is just matter and energy. We don't know how matter and energy create conscious, subjective experience, but we can know, as much as we know anything, that consciousness is an emergent property of our brain. (That is, we can manipulate consciousness by manipulating the brain - nothing mysterious required.)

However, knowing something and fully internalizing it are two different things.

When I was writing my latest book, Losing My Religions, in May 2022, I marveled that I was sleeping well with hardly any external help (e.g., medicines): 

As you would expect, I didn’t sleep at all [on the plane to Germany]. I have never slept on a plane, regardless of what I drink, what drugs I take, or how tired I am. (Not even earlier this month, with my overall sleep the best it has ever been. Lately, I’ve hardly taken any sleep meds at all!)

I attributed this to my life being better, including my mindfulness practice.

Ha-ha!

It turns out my improved sleep was dependent on the very high dose of nerve medicine I was taking for my spinal injury. (I was at the maximum dose for well over a year following the accident.) But as I started to wean myself off the drug (a process that is still ongoing) my sleep reverted back to its previous pattern, despite the antidepressant, meditation, and relative calm of my life. (And every sleep tip out there.)

This is simply another example showing that I am just a bag of chemicals. Yes, it feels like there is a "me" (self) in control. But everything is just chemical reactions, back and forth. (Unless it is all just a simulation.)

When I am able to stop my mind-churning and recognize this, it is quite enlightening. I hope it can be for you, too!