MailChimp

Monday, November 16, 2026

Pain Science

The website PainScience.com has updated their page Suffering, Disability & Pain with this new section:

Whose suffering counts? What about non-human animals?

A website about pain shouldn’t dodge those questions. Humans are not the only creatures that experience pain and suffering — we aren’t even the most numerous, not by a long shot — and we cause much of the non-human suffering. Our farmed animals suffer, and none more than chickens by the numbers. One Step for Animals is an advocacy group built on some grim arithmetic: it takes more than two hundred chickens to provide as many meals as one cow. So decades of earnest advice to minimize red meat — for health, for the climate — have had the practical effect of making people choose to eat many small animals instead of a few large ones, causing a net increase in animal suffering. Their “one step” is not veganism, which most people abandon anyway. It’s just: please don’t eat chickens!

Non-human suffering is a tangent here, but an ethically important one — and less of a tangent than it looks, because no humans are better placed to empathize with the suffering of other animals than those of us who know pain ourselves. Matt Ball is the co-founder and president of One Step and a long-time animal advocate who also lives with chronic pain, which he credits with stripping his ethics down to a single bottom line — “the irreducible heart of what matters is suffering.” For him, all that matters is how much serious suffering there is, and whether our choices actually reduce it.

This isn’t just sentiment. Gallagher’s “minimal self” is also what makes non-human suffering coherent. If suffering required a story about who you are and what your pain means for your future, then a dog could not suffer — and anyone who has lived with one knows better. Suffering that can obliterate reflection does not need reflection to get started, and so it is not exclusive to us.

No comments: